Mass Murder of Rats in India!

This is a reality check: Oh, how the animal liberationists must be writhing in anguish and grief about this story from India. It seems a tribe of lowest caste Indians is making a decent living killing rats to protect the crops of local farms:
In this impoverished tribal belt in southern Tamil Nadu state, catching rats has been a primary job for members of Chinnapayan's Irula tribe--an impoverished community of 3 million people at the bottom rung of the Hindu caste hierarchy who have often found themselves teetering on the brink of starvation.
But the introduction of innovative rat traps has remarkably reversed the Irulas' plight. By curbing the amount of rodents that have long menaced Indian farmers, the tribe has seen its income triple in the past three years, while bringing them new respect. The Irulas, who were once jeered by many locals as "rodent assassins," are now being touted as saviors by many farmers.
Under animal rights belief, the rats should be left alone. After all, animal liberationists believe that "a rat, is a pig, is a dog, is a boy," and hence, the mass killing of rats--sentient beings deemed by liberationists to be owed "equal consideration" with people--would seem to be a moral horror. I mean, the rats have as much right to eat as the people, right? Indeed, the rats were, I am sure, indigenous to the area long before people arrived, thus it should be the people who adjust to their presence and not the other way around.
This story reveals how the entire movement--as opposed to animal welfare-- should not be taken seriously. The urgent needs of people have to come first. Moreover, most people in the world don't have the luxury of presuming that a rat has a right to life or to eat. Indeed, the amazing prosperity and success of the West--and a resulting decadence and nihilism--is what spawned the very notion of animal rights.
Labels: Animal Rights. Real World


3 Comments:
The rat trappers make money by saving the crops from the nasty little animals - good. The only good rat is a barbecued rat!
Which brings up another thought... Y'know, that's in India. Aren't Hindus traditionally vegetarians? I wonder 'cause if the rodents are well handled they could very well be used to supplement their diets - and for everybody out there going "ewwwww" it's not any more dangerous than eating wild deer or prarie dogs or rabbits or otters, and people do that all the time. Wild game *does* have a higher risk of diseases, yes, but proper cooking of the animals will kill 99% of all bacteria.
Recipe for Chili Rat: http://www.earthportals.com/Portal_Messenger/ratfordinner.html
According to the article, rats are a treat in Thailand. It's a way to put the little monsters to good use, anyway.
I'm one of those nihilistic, decadent animal rights advocates (as opposed to animal liberationists--that's Peter Singer's bailiwick--but that's another comment), and my immediate thought about this interesting ethical dilemma is that there are too many humans on the planet, which leads to situations like starving Indians having to compete with starving rats. The ultimate answer is getting the population of humans down to a manageable size (say, about 1 billion) through free universal birth control so that nonhuman and human animals can coexist more peacefully, with enough food and habitat to accommodate both and avoid these horrible situations. I also wonder about those "innovative" rat traps. What exactly does that mean?
Thanks for stopping by lonebeaut: The story describes the traps. Hit the link.
To get the human race down to one billion would require far more than birth control. You are talking forced abortion, infanticide, and mass euthanasia of the elderly--and that still wouldn't work. It would also mean an implosion of society due to younger people not being around to help shoulder society as the generations pass.
In Africa, there is a great fear of societal implosion because of the high levels of HIV.
Some deep ecologists yearn for a pandemic of epic proportions to take us mostly out. I assume you used the term nihilistic ironically, and so I assume you don't yearn for some kind of plague.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home