Monday, January 29, 2007

Why Transhumanism Would Result in Stultifying Sameness

Dove

This ad has been around awhile, but I think it punctures the transhumanists' naive presumption that the post human future would be wildly individualistic and iconoclastic. I believe the opposite would be true. Just as today we are herded by social pressures and corporate advertisements into a conformist mindset--what my friend Ralph Nader calls "thinking corporate"--so too would we be pushed toward a stultifying sameness if transhumanists "seized control of human evolution." Only rather than being literally skin deep, as is true today with cosmetics and fashion, the sheep-like sameness would be implanted deep within our biological beings. Baaaa.

HT: Mark Pickup

5 Comments:

At January 29, 2007 , Blogger Simon Young said...

Wesley,
I've been meaning to ask - where did you get that favourite pejorative quote of yours "seize control" of evolution? Is it a James Hughes quote, perhaps? It's certainly not a turn of phrase I'd use - it sounds like the vocabulary of Marxist revolutionaries...

Simon Young
www.worldtranshumanistsociety.com

 
At January 29, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

Hi, Simon. I think it was Gregory Stock's book *Redesigning Humans.* "We know that Homo sapiens is not the final word in primate evolution, but few have yet grasped that we are on the cusp of profound biological change, poised to transcend our current form and character on a journey to destinations of new imagination... But give these emerging technologies a decade and they will be the cutting edge of human biological change. These developments will write a new page in the history of life, allowing us to seize control of our evolutionary future."

 
At January 29, 2007 , Blogger Foxfier said...

Mr. Smith-- does that sound like the opening to the next X-man movie to you?

 
At January 29, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

Yes. I think that is part of the transhumanist fantasy, actually. Thanks, foxfier, formerly sailorette.

 
At February 01, 2007 , Blogger Foxfier said...

Don't need the whole title.
*embarrassed*

Merging my online personalities.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home