Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Depopulate Berkeley!

A commentary by a woman named Edna Spector published in Berkeley's Daily Planet urges that the city's young lead the way to voluntarily making the human race extinct by not having children. Spector writes:

Friends! The hour of judgment is at hand for our planet. Doom is knocking on our door in the form of catastrophic climate change. Global warming not only threatens our so-called way of life, it threatens the very existence of the planet itself! Here in Berkeley, we must do more than our fair share to offset this crisis. Why more than our fair share? Quite simply because other communities cannot be relied on to do even their meager fair share in cutting back on carbon emissions. We must make up for what others fail to do on a global scale through our own heroic self-sacrifice. We cannot afford to wait until 2050 to meet our modest carbon emission reduction goals. Many of us who passed this measure will not even be alive then to implement it. By 2050 it will have been too late for this planet I fear, possibly far too late for all of the extinct species whose blood will be on our hands. This is no time for buying absolution through carbon credits or for half-assed symbolic measures which mostly have a feel good significance.

No, the time for bolder self-sacrifice has arrived. The only real, long term hope for the eco-sphere is a massive human population collapse, hopefully leading to the voluntary extinction of the human race. Already, a new urgency and groundswell of support is building for the idea that humans are a type of super toxin which the planet cannot sustain or support in the longterm. Cogent support for the voluntary extinction of the human race is well-articulated in all its ramifications and implications here : www.vhemt.org.

It is tempting to dismiss this hysterical hyperbole as either burning satire or pure fringe nuttery. Unfortunately, I think that she is serious. Moreover, she is right that her views are not entirely outside the mainstream of the political Left. Indeed, her essay is a prime example of the profound nihilism and misanthropy that seems to be infecting that side of the political road like a virus, to the point I have concluded that humanism is devolving into anti-humanism. (The political Right has problems too, but not anti-humanism.)

And catch this last bit:
Imagine if Berkeley has the honor of becoming the first human ghost town on earth to revert to a primal state of nature! The oaks old and new will flourish along the streams in which trout and salmon teem! Mountain lions will boldly roam the plains and not confine themselves to Wildcat Road in Tilden Park any longer. Perhaps bears from other regions of the state will finally return to what we call "Grizzly Peak Blvd." The grasslands will return to the slopes of the hills after forest fires clear them off and the air will blow pure and sweet over the bubbling creeks just as it once did when the ancestors of Running Wolf roamed the Bayshore in peace and harmony with all nature.
But what difference would it make if humans weren't around to appreciate it? Think about it: The dinosaurs lived for hundreds of millions of years and yet their grandeur was never once recognized in all that time. It took the exceptional species--us--to see the wonder. Similarly, if the bubbling creeks bubble and we aren't there to sigh in contentment, the planet might as well be as lifeless as Venus.

HT: Kathi Hamlon

9 Comments:

At September 25, 2007 , Blogger Ken Crawford said...

A small side note... there's a reference in here to Running Wolf, a reference that most who read this blog may not get:

Running Wolf is the organizer of the tree-sit-in at Memorial Stadium in Berkeley where they are trying to prevent the University of California from cutting down landscaping trees planted during the original construction of the stadium. The University is trying to expand the facilities and has plans to plant new landscaping trees, 3 for every one removed. I'm glad to see that nothing short of the extinction of Berkeley is good enough for Running Wolf and his cadre of protestors.

 
At September 25, 2007 , Blogger Don Nelson said...

I think this is a good development. If they voluntarily don't conceive, then maybe their ideas will vanish into history with them. That could save humanity. I could imagine a world without Telegraph Avenue, People's Park and other things Bezerkeley.

 
At September 25, 2007 , Blogger Jason said...

With any luck they will become so distraught with the plight that they will decide to hurry things along for themselves. Then we wont have to put up with this stupidity until they have the good sense to finally die of old age.

 
At September 26, 2007 , Blogger T E Fine said...

From Tabitha -

I'm Back!

Anyway, yeah, there've been people singing the praises of voluntary depopulation and human extinction for years and years. I believe I posted links to some of the weirder ones (there's one insane group that claims an alien being is encouraging them to kill themselves and eat dead humans to cut down on waste. Naturally, the leaders don't suicude becuase it's more important for them to get others to kill themselves right now).

What's bad is the human extinctionists hide behind honest and good programs, like encouraging people to adopt instead of having children because there are too many young people out there without stable homes that need adopting. And admirable admonishment made with the intent to do away with humanity.

You're right - they're well within the limits of mainstream Leftism. It's sad.

 
At September 26, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

Glad to have you back sharing your views, Tabs. I missed you.

 
At September 26, 2007 , Blogger OTE admin said...

Prove it that it is well within the "mainstream" of the so-called "left," which doesn't truly exist anyway outside the bounds of the more nutty of the posters at Democratic Underground.

It's like arguing the mainstream right argues in favor of abolishing women's suffrage.

 
At September 26, 2007 , Blogger T E Fine said...

Wesley -

I missed you too! BTW - I've been on a Dean Koontz kick ever since reading THE GOOD GUY (awesome book) and just now discovered that he pimped one of your books at the tail of his novel ONE DOOR AWAY FROM HEAVEN. Very cool.

(Personally, I think you missed me 'cause I'm the only one weird enough to have links to monkey-head-transplant websites...)

Back to business -

Susan, I think maybe it's less about being in Mainstream Left than about using good ideas to promote bad ones. Good idea - adopt children in need of happy families. Bad idea - stop having babies altogether. Good idea - respect the intrinsic rights of all humans. Bad idea - use those rights to promote suicide.

 
At September 26, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

I met Koontz after he promoted Culture of Death in One Door. He and his wife are now very good and treasured friends of Debra and me.

The idea of voluntary childlessness is, in a sense, like early eugenics. It begins with a matter of "choice" (not having children now, only having eugenically correct children then), but could quickly devolve as it did in eugenics (involuntary sterilization, the T-4 Program in Germany).

The only way to have radical depopulation of the human race is through mass killing of the human race. Some of these radical deep ecologists yearn for a pandemic to get that job done. But if that didn't happen, their thinking and rank utopianism could lead some to accept a "by whatever means necessary" mentality.

 
At September 26, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

Susan: By the Left (capital L) I mean the hard left, not liberals. Alas, some notable environmentalists have crossed the line into deep ecology, which is why I wrote "not entirely out of the mainstream," which is not the same as saying they are mainstream.

Besides, a book about the value to the planet if humans disappeared was #1 on the NYT best seller list for awhile, so these views are gaining some acceptance, it seems to me.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home