Thursday, June 07, 2007

A.B. 374: Ding Dong the Bill is Dead!


I just received a report that A.B. 374, which would legalize assisted suicide in California, does not have the votes to pass in the Assembly and hence, will not be brought up for a vote. This is a great, hard fought, victory for a strange bedfellow political coalition consisting of liberals and conservatives, the secular and the pious, pro life and pro choice, medical professionals and advocates for the poor. I don't have a link to the story about it in the Sacramento Bee, but this is the gist:

Hotly contested legislation to allow doctors to prescribe fatal medication to terminally ill patients was shelved Thursday in the Assembly. Assembly Bill 374 lacked enough votes for passage and time was running out, with the Assembly facing a Friday deadline for acting upon bills by its members. "The people are there and the politicians aren't," said Will Shuck, chief of staff for Assemblywoman Patty Berg, a Eureka Democrat who helped write the bill.

AB 374 is dead for the year. It could be resurrected in January, Shuck said, but he is not sure whether that will happen.

A similar measure, one of the Legislature's most hotly contested, died in a Senate committee last year.

It will be. Assisted suicide advocates are truly dedicated to their agenda. Still, as I have said, I think the next big battleground will be Washington State, where there will probably be an initiative on the issue next year.

I fully appreciate the reasons why people might be attracted to and support assisted suicide. But, as I discuss fully in Forced Exit, it is a siren song that, in my view, would crash our society on the rocks and expose the most defenseless among us to terrible exploitation.

Labels:

6 Comments:

At June 07, 2007 , Blogger Tony Jones said...

Great! Now we can watch the suicide rate for the elderly and the sick continue to skyrocket!

 
At June 08, 2007 , Blogger Lydia McGrew said...

That's great news, Wesley. Thanks for keeping us in the loop on it. I'm actually a little surprised that Oregon rather than California is our only state with assisted suicide. California always seems to be the leader in all manner of craziness. We dodged the bullet there--or rather, the people who would have been killed under the bill did.

 
At June 08, 2007 , Blogger Royale said...

Wesley,

Although we disagree on this and many other issues, I respect your crusade and only wish that I might have the courage, when the time is right, to retire from law to pursue my calling a public service.

But I promise I will do you the honor of reading Forced Exit. Then, I'm sure I'll nit-pick it ;)

 
At June 08, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

Thanks, Royale. Nit pick away!

Perhaps a pro bono gig will come up at your firm and you can have your cake and eat it, too.

 
At June 08, 2007 , Blogger Royale said...

Off-topc and I'll stop with this...

What I'd rather do (by far), is go to med school and then work for Doctors without borders (or the US Army) and fight infectious disease in the 3rd world.

But given the immense time and financial costs, I'm wrestling with the feasibility of all that.

Maybe 6 months of the year, of-counsel litigation for the big pharmas, then the rest of the time in the 3rd world providing the medicines I protect from the 3rd world.

That ironic twist would totally be me.

(but don't worry, despite my libertarian leanings, I would never, ever actually intentionally prescribe a fatal dose even if the patient wanted it)

 
At June 08, 2007 , Blogger Tony Jones said...

Good luck with that, Royale. I wish you all the best. Perhaps one day companies like Pfizer will get sued for the harm they've caused in the past by blocking generic AIDS medication for the 3rd world.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home