Wednesday, March 14, 2007

Misplaced Suicide Priorities

Apparently there has been a backlash against advertising with "suicide" themes. From the Seattle Post Intelligencer story: Washington Mutual has stopped running a spot that showed actors playing bankers poised atop a building as if about to jump. These ads are clearly not pro-suicide, but are oriented toward humor.

It seems to me that not only is this overly sensitive, but it misses the real pro-suicide content of the public discourse. There have been many stories published in mainstream media that give a positive spin choosing suicide. Indeed, Jack Kevorkian became such a media hero that Time invited him as an honored guest to its 75th anniversary gala. Assisted suicide advocacy explicitly states that suicide is acceptable in some circumstances. And yet, not only is there no backlash, but there is much editorial support for the idea.
Oregon has such a terrible problem with elder-suicide that the state is looking for ways to reduce the toll. The Dutch are very worried about a youth suicide epidemic. And the leaders of these pro-assisted suicide sovereignties somehow miss the profound irony: This is the same state that says suicide in some cases is now a sacred right. Such mixed messages in the law do far more harm than humorous ads.

Finally, a brief story: A few months ago I received an e-mail from a suicidal person. I wrote back asking for contact information. He gave me his phone number and permission to have someone call him. I tried to find a suicide prevention center in his area code. There were none. I had to find an adjoining county to get the man help.

This really alarmed me. When I was a young lawyer in Los Angeles, suicide prevention education was everywhere. I received training. There were ubiquitous ads almost begging suicidal people to call suicide prevention hotlines. Maybe it's me, but I don't see such emphasis any more. Is it possible we are becoming less "anti-suicide?" I say yes.

Labels:

2 Comments:

At March 14, 2007 , Blogger John Howard said...

That's great of you find help for that suicidal man. Do you get emails like that because of your writing about the subject?

It's possible that all those ads we used to see on trains didn't have a positive effect, perhaps in some cases they depressed people and gave them ideation, I don't know. Now we have other messages giving people the ideas, without offering a hotline number.

 
At March 14, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

I only mention that instance because I was shocked at how hard it was to find a local suicide prevention center for the man.

I am often written to asking for help and advice on matters of intensity. I do what I can, which is often not very much.

I have never heard that suicide prevention ads have an unintended negative effect. I just think it came to be perceived as less important as our culture changed. I could be wrong, of course.

Thanks for writing John.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home