Monday, February 26, 2007

A Case of Suicide Tourism in Oregon?

A story in the San Francisco Chronicle today inadvertently disclosed what may be a case of assisted suicide tourism in Oregon. The story is about a pagan memorial service for a woman named Heather MacAllister, who was notable locally for promoting fat burlesque. (Remember, this is San Francisco.) Here is what caught my eye: "On what would have been MacAllister's 38th birthday, members of the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community gathered to say goodbye to the performer and activist who ended her life Feb. 13 in Portland, Ore., through assisted suicide after a battle with ovarian cancer...MacAllister, a Michigan native, moved to San Francisco in 2005 to create the Big Burlesque and Fat Bottom Revue, featuring and celebrating large women." No indication she ever moved to Oregon.

If she was not a resident of Oregon, the assisted suicide was illegal there. But the state's regulators would almost certainly never find out about it since virtually all they know about individual assisted suicides comes from information supplied by the death doctors, who would almost certainly not disclose that they assisted the suicide of a non resident. And even if the state regulators were informed, they don't have the authority to investigate. All they could do is refer it to a district attorney, who, if past irregularities that have come to light in Oregon are any indication, would not give the matter a high law enforcement priority.

The residence requirement "safeguard" in Oregon is a total joke, of course. If I wanted to become a resident of Oregon today, all I would have to do is fly there, take out a motel room, and claim Oregon as my home.

I am going to see if I can find out more about this. But even if my suspicions are right, don't expect the Oregon authorities to do anything. The entire program there is run on the principle of hear no evil, see no evil, and speak no evil. The guidelines aren't actually intended to protect, but merely give false assurance.

Labels:

2 Comments:

At March 02, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

This from a reader in today's e-mail:
"Heather MacAllister was in fact a resident of Portland Oregon. She moved there with her partner in October, 2006. I don't know why, but in the article you read, all the memorial services weren't listed. Heather was greatly loved, and admired for her extensive social activism, and fabulous portfolio of performances, so there were services in her honor in Portland, OR, NY, S.F., Boston, and Michigan, basically anywhere she had built a community.

Also, what did you mean by the comment "this is san francisco" when referring to Heather's work with the big burlesque? It sounds condescending, to me.

Anyway, I just thought I'd let you know that your suspicion about Heather not having been a resident of Oregon is wrong."

 
At March 05, 2007 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

This from a blog that came to my attention.

"Maybe I need to stay the hell out of the blogosphere, but I came across this post, ironically on a "Bioethics" blog, authored by an ignorant asswipe by the name of Wesley Smith. He alleged that Heather's choice was a case of "suicide tourism." He also threatened to "look into it further."

I submitted the following comment, but the comments are moderated so I can't imagine it will actually appear:

This was not a case of suicide "tourism." If you would have googled for half a second more, you would have found multiple other sources that reference Heather MacAllister moving to Oregon over 9 months ago to escape the high price of living in San Francisco.

I am Heather MacAllister's partner and I can personally attest that her decision was carefully made, and only made after fighting stage III ovarian cancer for three years with nothing but love, raw courage and her friends at her side. Assisted suicide would not have been my choice, not by a long shot, but it was her choice. And anyone who would have taken this choice away from her knows nothing of "ethics."

Heather had a memorial service in a city where she was no longer living because her courage, love of--and fight for-- life inspired so many. She was a person who wanted to make the world a better place and she did. It's a travesty that her last choices are being maligned by an elitist, self-righteous, ignorant prig who can't even be bothered to research the allegation he is making.

You disgust me"

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home