Stem Cell Cornucopia in the After Birth
Amniotic fluid continues to show great potential for stem cell research. So do every other by product of live births--placenta, umbilical cord blood, amniotic membrane, even cord tissue. As my good friend Richard Doerflinger put it, "Each new birth not only means a new stage in life for that particular child, but also the arrival of new resources that could save lives (beginning with the life of that child himself or herself, since these cells are first and foremost a genetically ideal 'repair kit' for this individual)."
Of course, the AP story quotes Robert Lanza of Advanced Cell Technology, who misled the world by claiming he had created ES cells from 10 cell embryos without destroying the embryos themselves, when he had done no such thing. And the reporter didn't even mention that these non embryonic stem cell breakthroughs are potential competition for Advanced Cell Technology. No wonder Lanza said that these stem cells "don't perform as many tricks as embryonic stem cells" when actually, the so-called ESC "tricks" seem more theoretical than actually accomplished.


4 Comments:
There must be something big going on here because even the Reno Gazette Journal picked it up and said it was an non-embryonic stem cell source. Holy Second Hand Smokes. Usually they call it a stem cell success without saying the source is non-embryonic.
My question is whether or not this is old news. I think your first sentence indicates it is. Why are they catching up now? Could there be any political cover for opposing HR 3? Probably not.
I stilll can't believe Robert Lanza gets quoted. The AP has to know he's duped them. There has to be someone better, though Maureen Condic suggested that there are fewer embryonic stem cell research supporters in her First Things essay. Could that be true too?
I'm confused as well. All the reports I've seen indicate that this is "new" news. But I thought ESCs coming from umbilical cords/ amniocentesis was "old" news.
Maybe they figured out a way to cultivate the umbilical ESCs better or something, but I can't figure out what is new about this.
I think what is the news is that they are apparently close to pluripotent in that they have been morphed into cells from the three types. Also, easier to collect.
So you have non-controversial sources for potential treatments, flexible cells that carry less risk than the controversial sources, and you get a small person to boot. This may be old news but it's good to see that people are taking it seriously.
Keep all this in mind when you buy flowers for all the mamas you know on Mother's Day.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home