Wednesday, August 30, 2006

Stem Cell Quacks Taking Advantage of the Ill

I have posted stories like this before, but it bears frequent repeating: Stem cell research--even of the ethical kind such as adult and umbilical cord blood stem cells--remains, with some exceptions, at the formative stage. Yes, there are exciting early human trials ongoing, many of which are showing much promise. But the key word here is "early." Not only do scientists have to find out whether these potential therapies can work, but they also have to design proper therapeutic courses of treatment. This takes time and there are no shortcuts.

The story linked above describes how scam artists are taking advantage of ill people by allegedly charging tens of thousands of dollars to inject them with stem cells, leaving some of the patients worse off than before. In an era of potentially exciting medical breakthroughs, quackery is an ever present danger.

I often hear from desperate people wanting to take advantage of the "new" stem cell treatments. My advice to them, as it is here, is to be patient. Ethical regenerative medicine offers much hope. But it isn't here, yet. But there is no substitute for doing the slow and grueling science required to ensure that it is safe and to learn how to provide the best effect with the fewest side effects. In other words, if an overseas stem cell protocol seems to good to be true, it probably is. Or to put it another way, be careful out there.

3 Comments:

At August 31, 2006 , Blogger Royale said...

So, would you be willing to praise the media for stories like this? Surely, something like this cautions the public that the promises and technology of the stem cell research are limited. Hence, it cuts against your idea the media is biased in their promotion of the unlimited potential of ESC.

 
At August 31, 2006 , Blogger Wesley J. Smith said...

Well, no. First, it was a UK story. Second, warning against quackery in non embryonic stem cell treatments would work in favor of the media's general bias that downplays advances in adult/umbilical cord blood stem cells and hypes embryonic. Nice try, though.

 
At September 01, 2006 , Blogger Royale said...

That't not the question I asked as I've seen similar stories from American news media.

Furthermore, I think the public conflates ASC and ESC in general, thus discussing the problems of quack ASC therapy would shift the ideas and politics of ESC.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home